A large defect in a sidewalk caused the plaintiff to trip and fall and be severely injured. The investigation revealed that the defective condition had been left unrepaired for 14 months prior to the injury. The defense argued that the plaintiff should have known of the defective condition, because she had walked on the sidewalk once previously. Evidence also revealed that the sidewalk had poor lighting. The plaintiff sustained a fractured humerus and underwent shoulder replacement surgery. After three months of physical therapy, the plaintiff was left with permanent impairment and limited range of motion in the shoulder.